Dissertation - Racism in British Tabloids (Selected Chapters)
Dissertation title: In recent times the British tabloid press has claimed to report news which is unbiased. Investigate such a claim and discuss whether a racist attitude has been adopted in the coverage of recent international events.
Recently, the British Isles has been the destination for many political and economic migrants; consequently the issues of asylum and terrorism have become topics widely covered in relation to migration by all sections of the media
This paper presents the results of an interdisciplinary study on tabloid press coverage of ethnic affairs in the UK. Apart from providing the reader with a thorough content analysis of the material, the study introduces a detailed discourse analytical approach to the study of the ways in which ethnic minorities are portrayed in the press.
The study focuses on two UK tabloids, The Daily Mirror and The Daily Mail, each representing the left and the right. The author has intended that by prioritising these two papers an overall general attitude of British tabloids may be determined.
In conclusion the author notes that negative themes such as terrorism, crime, abduction, drugs, violence etc are abundantly reported and magnified in relation to subordinate groups. According to the paper this is something that is most typical in prejudiced racist literature.
The study further concludes that the tabloids are also more likely to define people by race. The study asserts that there is a high probability that one third of all actors featuring in news articles would be defined by race; the majority of which would be from ethnic minorities.
Overall it is found that the right-wing press predominantly portrays race issues negatively, where as the left-wing press is rather more balanced in its’ attitude towards ethnic minorities.
Chapter One (Introduction)
On the 2nd of February 1900, a British liner carrying refugees from
On Holocaust Memorial Day in 1938, regarding Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi persecution to Britain, The Daily Mail said: “The way stateless Jews from Germany are pouring in from every port of this country is becoming an outrage, the number of aliens entering the country through the back door is a problem to which the Daily Mail has repeatedly pointed.’
In recent times, the
This paper aims to indulge in seeking to clarify whether British tabloid newspapers have covered recent issues in an unbiased, impartial manner or whether on the other hand a racist, biased attitude, similarly to the one that was adopted at the time of the arrival of Jewish migrants over a hundred years ago, has been adopted.
The year 2003 has most certainly been an eventful year. To begin with, in April the invasion of
In January a chemical substance thought to be ricin was found in the possession of ‘Algerian asylum seekers’ in
Six days later on the 21st of January, police raided the Finsbury Park Mosque; consequently the raid drew Abu Hamza, dubbed ‘Captain Hook’ by some of the tabloids, into the media limelight.
This paper aims to choose a collection of tabloid articles from the period between 1st January and 30th of February 2003 and see whether a racist attitude has been adopted in the coverage of recent events. If such an assumption can be found to be true then the paper will further analyse the manner by which such discrimination manifests itself.
After having set the background for this study, chapter two aims to present a brief review of the literature studied and used in the writing of this analysis. Moving further on, chapter three will contain an outline of the methodology adopted in researching the issue, thereafter the actual analysis will be undertaken in chapters four and five. Chapter four will be concerned with an analysis of the articles through the quantitative mode whereas chapter five will focus on analysing the articles in a qualitative manner. Finally the conclusion will be presented in chapter six.
Chapter Five (Conclusion)
All of the
Previous studies concluded that in the 60’s the primary concern of the press was with keeping ethnic minorities out. Issues pertaining to immigration and the views of right-wing hardliners such as Enoch Powell were given excessive coverage (Hartmann, Husband & Clark 1974, p. 174). Subsequent studies analysing coverage in the 1970’s found there had been “a shift of concern” and that ethnic minorities were seen in the press as “the outsider within.” (see Troyna 1981, p41).
In this paper, having analysed news articles we find that at the beginning of the 21st century tabloids from the right have, as in the 1960’s, aimed at keeping refugees out and portrays them as a problem. As before much coverage is given to immigration and the views of hard-line politicians are given substantial coverage with white liberals and ethnic minorities belittled and criticised.
On the contrary, the left shuns hardliners and portrays the positive aspects of immigration. The question whether such attitudes are on account of traditional political attitudes and sympathies is an issue, which has a great probability. But fundamentally we can say that The Mail and the tabloids in general, supports and endorses draconian measures against ‘dominated’ groups where as the left does not do so.
In his study Van Dijk found that the coverage of race related issues in European societies has “become lees blatantly racist, but that stereotypes and the definition of minorities as a ‘problem’ or even as a threat is still prevalent”. (see Van Dijk:1991 p.245)